Pin It
If you are from the Chicago area, you probably recognize the bad boy in the picture above. The Italian Beef sandwich is a culinary institution in the Second City. Each beef stand has its own method and thus, flavor and texture, so everybody seems to have a favorite. I was introduced to the sandwich in my late teens and after a few years and samples of many variations, I got the familiar voice in my head--"I want to try this at home." After much searching and tweaking of recipes, I struck gold with this process. If you have been transplanted to some other city or country and can't get it or if you're still around and always wanted to try your hand at making the succulent, juicy beef yourself-- have I got a plan for you!
In order to help you make your very own Italian Beef sandwices at home, I have included a few step-by-steps below.
Prepare the ingredients for the rub, reserving 1 tablespoon of the mixture to season the juice. Massage the rub on all sides of the meat. Allow to rest for 1 hour at room temperature. This ensures that the meat will cook evenly.
Roast the meat at 450° F for 15 minutes. Reduce the heat to 350° F and cook until the internal temperature reaches 130°-135° F for medium rare. Cooking the meat to medium rare is important for tenderness. The meat will be further cooked when warmed in the juice before assembling the sandwich. Once rested, tightly wrap the roast in double layers of aluminum foil then plastic wrap and chill for several hours, preferably overnight. Chilling makes it easier to slice. The meat needs to be sliced as thin as possible, preferably with an electric knife. In fact, I would not even try slicing it by hand. Thick cuts of meat make for a tough sandwich.
Remove the roast from the pan, lightly tent with foil, and set aside to rest for 20-30 minutes; reserve any meat drippings. Meanwhile, deglaze the pan with boullion cubes, water, reserved seasoning from the rub mixture, and any reserved meat drippings.
Once chilled, slice shave the meat as thin as possible (I cannot stress this enough), preferably with an electric knife, unless you can get your hands on a meat slicer.
I am talking paper thin slices, my friends. They don't have to be uniform, but ultra thin is key. Electric knives are fairly inexpensive, so go get one. I use mine all the time for meats and roasts.
Juice and meat can be made a day ahead and I recommend it highly.
The next day, heat the juice over a low heat and allow the meat to soak for no more than one minute. Otherwise, it becomes tough and chewy. Dress your sandwich with some juice, sautéed green peppers if you like (we like), hot giardinara (we like Pagliacci Hot Italian Pepper Spread in oil), and a good ladle of more juice (or dip the whole sandwich). Push up your sleeves, elbows up, and dig in. Don't forget the
fries!